There seems to be some kind of compulsion in our society to have dogs who don’t know each other greet one another on leash when out in public. Am I the only one who finds this a bit weird?
If you know anything about me, you know that I’m a hard-core proponent of canine socialization. However, I don’t quite understand why my dogs would need to greet any canine they meet on the street.
As a trainer, I happen to know that many dogs who are out and about probably shouldn’t be. I know how common it is for owners of reactive/aggressive dogs to be in denial. Dogs who have bitten people and other dogs can still be walking down the street, at the pet store or in the park with their owners.
I have the advantage of enough education and experience to read dogs more effectively than the average owner, so I feel pretty confident in knowing which dogs I should absolutely avoid. But for most of my clients the prospect of allowing their dog to greet a strange dog is a hold your breath, cross your fingers, crap shoot.
Another problem is that so many dogs have not been taught how to greet other dogs appropriately. To add to that issue, many dog owners don’t understand normal, appropriate dog behavior. Time and again I’ve seen a friendly yet highly inappropriate dog greet another dog in a rude (but friendly) manner. When the dog being greeted gives a very appropriate and much warranted correction, he is deemed mean or aggressive. It’s all backwards!
My strong preference is for dogs who are out on walks to learn that other dogs are of no consequence. My perfect world would have dog owners waving to each other and saying hello with no response from the dogs.
I would love to see dogs having a rich social life through well-run daycare, back yard play groups or safe dog parks so that walking with their owners could simply be about walking with their owners.
Filed under: Relationship with Dogs, Socialization, Training

I agree whole heardly with everything you are saying. I am also a dog trainer and run a boarding, doggy care / training faciltiy for over 20 years. One of the biggest complaints are that people insist on their dogs meeting no matter what my student says, or petting a dog again no matter what a owner may ask of them. The I am in training vests seem to help……. Thanks for this blog may I put a link to this post on my blog. pawstive musings.
Absolutely! And thanks for reading!
~Cindy
I totally agree with you that dogs should not be required to meet when on leash. I’m probably taking this too personally but as an owner of a reactive dog I don’t think it is fair to say that you shouldn’t walk reactive dogs. They still need exercise and stimulation. I wouldn’t take my dog to a dog park or a pet store but I have taken responsibility and am working on training and desensitizing my dog which requires taking him out onto the streets. In my experience people with reactive dogs (who are not in denial) are generally more responsible and aware of dog behavior and etiquette than those who have happy go lucky, social dogs. I would never get my dog close enough to meet another dog (putting him past his threshold) but that doesn’t mean other people haven’t tried!
Thanks for the great post and reminder to others who may not be aware that their dogs don’t have to greet every dog they meet… humans certainly don’t shake hands with everyone we see!
I immediately regretted not mentioning situations like yours, which I have been in! As the responsible owner of a reactive dog I would specifically seek out posted on-leash areas to walk. Not only did other dog owners want to bring their dogs up to meet mine, but it was rare that we could find a place where dogs weren’t off-leash. The owners of those off-leash dogs felt it was okay because they’re dogs were friendly. Guess who gets dirty looks when their dog snarks and snarls at the oncoming goofball canine?!
Thanks for bringing this up! There are plenty of people who are responsibly walking reactive dogs, dogs in training, dogs who don’t know how to greet well, show dogs, service dogs and lots of other dogs who simply don’t want/need another dog to approach them.
~Cindy
Love the idea of the “I am in training” vests. Where can I get one?
It is always good to hear that you are not alone. With this line of thinking and a reactive dog who does well until a goofball dog who has no recall comes up……………. As far as the vest I will look in my files, can’t remember off the top of my head. We are jamming today at the Doggy Dude Ranch.
http://www.pawsitivedog.com/DogInTrainingVest.html
One vest that I found. For dogs in training.
Hi Cindy,
Thanks for this great post. I had an appt this a.m. on just this same thing. I’ve never understood why people want their dogs to run up to every dog and say “hi”. Saying that a dog is a social creature isn’t a good reason because so are we. Yet when I walk through the mall I don’t say hi to everyone I pass. People with kids don’t have their kids go say hi to every other kid on the sidewalk.
I tell my clients that most people don’t tell you if their dog has issues. They are using your dog as an experiment to try to up their percentage of successful interactions. And when it doesn’t go well they just say “oops” and move along. In the meantime it has probably made your dog wonder how much he can now trust you to not put him in a possibly dangerous situation.
Thank you for this article!
Best,
Laura Bourhenne
Suzanne Clothier has a great article on her website about this same topic. Click here to read it.
http://flyingdogpress.com/content/view/42/97/